The Refugee Lawyer Who Discovered the Law Was Part of the Problem

Portrait of E. Tendayi Achiume, a scholar of refugee and migration law.

In Johannesburg, E. Tendayi Achiume represented refugees and asylum seekers trying to stay in South Africa. She had gone into human rights law believing it could protect people in danger. She later described the work as meaningful and emotionally devastating. What troubled her was that even when the rules were followed, the people she represented could still be left exposed. Some of the barriers they faced were written into the law itself.

Achiume had once expected to spend her life asking a different kind of question. Born in Zambia, she moved several times growing up and pictured herself becoming a physicist or an engineer. At UWC Atlantic in Wales, a class on political thought introduced her to Hobbes, Locke and Machiavelli. Here was a subject that asked where governments got their authority and what people could demand of them. She had never expected to study in the United States. She applied to Yale and went.

She finished college in 2005 and earned her law degree three years later. From Yale she went to Johannesburg to clerk at South Africa’s Constitutional Court for Deputy Chief Justice Dikgang Moseneke and Justice Yvonne Mokgoro. A fellowship from Yale then helped her make the move from the court to Lawyers for Human Rights. She stayed in the same city, but the questions looked different when somebody was sitting across from her, waiting to learn whether they would be allowed to stay.

Representing a client meant trying to get that person through the system. Achiume wanted to understand how the system had come to work that way in the first place. A clinical teaching fellowship at UCLA gave her a way into academic life, and she joined the law faculty in 2014. The cases in Johannesburg had given her questions that stretched well beyond South Africa. Her research took her into the history of how wealthy countries came to hold such power over who could cross their borders.

In an article called “Migration as Decolonization,” she asked readers to think about what happens when a country treats someone from a former colony as a complete stranger. Colonial rule had already tied those places together, sometimes for generations. It had also helped create some of the inequalities that give people reasons to move. In another article, “Racial Borders,” she looked at how a rule that never mentions race can still carry forward older patterns of exclusion.

In 2017, the United Nations Human Rights Council appointed her its special rapporteur on racism, racial discrimination, xenophobia and related intolerance. She was the first woman to hold the mandate. Over five years, she examined discrimination, raised concerns with governments and reported her findings to the United Nations. In 2023 she received a MacArthur Fellowship. She joined Stanford Law School in 2024, where she teaches and writes about human rights, migration and refugee law.

An asylum case in Johannesburg began with a question about one person’s future: Could they stay? Achiume has spent much of her career asking a question that rarely comes up in that room. How did one side of the desk get so much power to decide where the person on the other side could live?

Photo: © John D. and Catherine T. MacArthur Foundation, used with permission.

Next
Next

The Letter That Belonged to Five People